Membership is always individual and at the discretion of the general membership. All members must publish or broadcase substantive reviews or critical commentary that exhibits considerable depth and breadth of knowledge in cinema. These reviews must be of newly-released films and must be presented/published on a regular basis. Reviews must involve considerations of artistic merit and entertainment value. Analysis from a specifically doctrinal or moral perspective does not qualify, nor do reviews of DVDs and/or videos. To remain members in good standing, members must also pay the annual membership dues, regularly update the Society web site, vote in the Association's end-of-year award balloting, and publicize the year end award results as well as any other pertinent film critic society business.

Members who fall into more than one of the three memberhip categories must meet the requirements of their primary category (e.g. a print critic whose reviews also appear on the ancillary web site must meet the print requirements).